Home            Artist links            Label link

Asia - Aria

Artist: Asia
Title: Aria
Label: Bullet Proof Records
Length(s): 48 minutes
Year(s) of release: 1994
Month of review: 06/1994

Line up

Geoff Downes - keyboards
John Payne - lead and backing vocals, bass, guitar
Al Pitrelli - guitars
Michael Sturgis - drums

Tracks

1) Anytime 4.57
2) Are You Big Enough? 4.08
3) Desire 5.20
4) Summer 4.07
5) Sad Situation 3.59
6) Don't Cut The Wire (brother) 5.20
7) Feels Like Love 4.50
8) Remembrance Day 4.19
9) Enough's Enough 4.37
10) Military Man 4.10
11) Aria 2.27

All tracks written by Geoff Downes and John Payne.

Summary

I'm not a big fan of Asia, still I think they deserve attention and I will try to judge them on their merits and not on the fact that they make progressive rock that is very much in my vein.

The music

I believe this to be the seventh album by this band up to now, including the very well sold selftitled one, Alpha, Astra, Now and Then, Live in Moscow and Aqua. The first line-up reminds me a bit of UK: a lot of great names but a lot of ego as well. With Asia it went downhill quickly as they were never able to sell enough to satisfy all the managers involved. Aqua featuring Downes, Palmer and Howe wasn't very well received (I haven't heard it though so I can't compare), but the latest news has been that Asia has risen from its artistic grave. The new band features only Geoff Downes from the very first line-up (also known from the Buggles, Yes and GTR). This motivated me to take a closer look at this album (though I will not examine song by song).

Taking a closer look a found the artwork is as always very good by a certain Mr. Dean that some of you might remember from most of the Yes covers. An inspection of the songlengths reveals that a songbased approach is probably that what has been taken: my guess were confirmed after the first listen. The songs are very much in the AOR fashion with light symphonic overtones, mostly due to the use of synthesizers. The fact that I say AOR is based on two things: the vocals by Payne (that remind me somewhat of Clarkin of Magnum fame, though less characteristic (which is positive I think)) and most of the songs are in the refrain format. This is not anything new you might say, because bands like old-Asia and GTR were also like this. True, and it's also these bands that can be used as reference (not very strange I suppose). It is worthwhile to note that the guitar isn't very prominent on this album (as opposed to many other melodic bands of this kind).

The strengths of albums like these is always in the melodies of the songs. The playing and production is usually alright and the albums usually do not create an atmosphere. The lyrics are down to earth as was to be suspected. The melodies range from reasonable to very good. All songs support on the quite inventive playing by Downes and the Paynes vocals. Some songs turn out to be quite bombastic (in the Magnum style) by means of the vocal harmonies and the keyboardparts (Desire, Anytime), while others are a bit dreamy (Summer, Feels like love). And others vary a bit along the way: for instance Don't Cut the Wire is mid-tempo in the beginning but accelerates at the end. Another song is Remembrance day. The song is about the Vietnam veterans that have been forgotten (at least that's what I gathered). The guitarwork is very prominent in this song and moves towards bands like Threshold and maybe a bit of Dream Theater though less frantic. Fact is that this song is quite heavy.

They did save the best little goody to the last, because Aria is the pinnacle of this album. It's a sort of a classical/piano reprise of Desire. Comparing this album with Asia by Asia I must say that the main differences are that the melodies on Asia are more poppy (Heat of the Moment, Only Time Will Tell, Sole Survivor, One Step Closer, the chorus of Here Comes The Feeling). I'd say the style of new-Asia is a bit like Only Time Will Tell in the less poppy parts of he song with less emphasis on guitar and more on melody and keyboard. The high point of Asia is IMO Without You and I think that no song on Aria reaches this level, but on the average I like Aria better than Asia (but feel free to disagree). I also think that Payne's voice better fits the music (I mean Wetton has done so many other things, very good things that he doesn't really fit in).

Conclusion

Although I'm not a big fan of their style they have managed to surprise me with a very consistent (no bad apples), melodic and at times bombastic album that doesn't leave the beaten paths of melodic rock very often, but has a lot going for it due to the excellent melodies and freshness in their songs. They outrank the latest Magnum releases easily by virtue of those melodies and the inventive playing by Downes. The album has its weak parts though in the sometimes very accessible structures (though I still had to listen to it a few times to appreciate the melodies and look through the sing-a-long choruses, which are always a pain in the neck to me), but that's more because of the musical style as a whole. Within that style however this album stands out and any fan of this kind of music is invited to try it out; you won't be disappointed. People with a more daring appetite for music might think it over. Asia hasn't become progressive, they're still melodic is a better way to describe it. Although this has been a fairly positive review I must admit that save Aria I will probably not play the CD again.
© Jurriaan Hage