Artificial Intelligence and law
The law is a societally important and scientifically rich and challenging application domain of artificial intelligence. AI & law is one of my two main research fields, together and overlapping with computational argumentation.
I was the program chair of JURIX 1994 and ICAIL 2001, a keynote speaker at JURIX 1998, ICAIL 2009 and JURIX 2024, and a local organiser of JURIX 2003 and JURIX 2018 and of several smaller events in the Netherlands. Two of them resulted in special issues of the Artificial Intelligence and Law journal: a JURIX 1996 workshop on Dialectical Legal Argument: Formal and Informal Models (special issue in 2000) and an ECAI 2016 workshop on AI for Justice (special issue in 2017). Since 2019 I am a co-organiser and lecturer of the AI & Law Summer Schools at the European University Institute, Florence (Italy). I was a member of the IAAIL executive committee between 2002 and 2007 and its president in 2008-2009. I was the president of the JURIX Foundation for Legal Knowledge-based Systems between 2011 and 2015.
Much of my research in AI & law has been on computational models of legal argumentation. My early work was on the following topics.
- Legal reasoning about evidence. See, for example, two articles in Law, Probability & Risk
(2004, 2014), my
2004 AI & Law Journal paper with Floris Bex, Chris Reed and Doug Walton on formalising evidential argument schemes, my
ICAIL-2005 paper on accrual of arguments, an edited volume on Legal Evidence and Proof: Statistics, Stories, Logic, a co-edited special issue of Topics in Cognitive Science on Models of Rational Proof in Criminal Law,
and two double PhD projects:
My current work in AI and Law focuses on the following main themes:
- The computer judge. The recent successes in machine learning have led many in the legal world to believe that the computer judge is near. Some recent algorithms that predict outcomes of legal cases are often cited as evidence. I believe that these expectations are largely based on misconceptions of what such predictive models can do for the law. I have recently (co-)written two papers in Dutch journals about this: Prakken (NJB 2018, English translation) and Bex & Prakken (AA 2020, English translation). With Floris Bex I also have an ICAIL 2021 paper on the relevance of algorithmic decision predictors for judicial decision making, and a JURIX 2021 paper on whether predictive justice can improve the consistency of judicial decision-making. My NJB 2018 paper was cited by the Dutch minister of Justice in a letter to the Dutch parliament. In 2017 I was interviewed about the 'robot judge' in the Dutch newspaper Trouw.
- Legal applications of large language models. Large language models are a revolutionary recent development in AI, with potentially many legal applications. On October 8, 2021 (one year before the introduction of ChatGPT!) I commented on potential legal applications (in Dutch) at the annual meeting of the Dutch Association for Lawyers (NJV). In the summer of 2024 I published an overview paper On evaluating legal-reasoning capabilities of generative AI. On Sept. 9th, 2024 I gave my inaugural address (original Dutch version), (translated English version) at Utrecht University, in which I discussed the potentials and dangers of using large language models for legal reasoning tasks.
Associations,
interest groups, resources, blogs, ...
Workshops and Conferences
Future:
- 38th International Conference on Legal Knowledge and Information Systems (JURIX 2025)
Turin (Italy), 9-11 December 2025.
- 21st International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Law (ICAIL 2026), Singapore, June 2026.
Past:
- International Conferences on Artificial Intelligence and Law
(ICAIL).
- International Conferences on Legal Knowledge and Information Systems
(JURIX).
-
Summer Schools on Law and Logic,
Fiesole, Forence (Italy).
-
AI & Law Summer Schools. Fiesole, Florence (Italy).
-
LEX Summerschools on managing legal sources. Florence/Ravenna (Italy).
- International Workshops on Juris-informatics
(JURISIN), Japan.
- International Conferences on Alternative Methods of Argumentation in Law, Brno, Czech republic:
2011,
2012,
2013.
- Workshop on Reasoning about Responsible Agency in AI
Amsterdam (The Netherlands), 16-17 May, 2023.
-
Symposium on
Law and Artificial Intelligence: Not a World Apart, Utrecht (The Netherlands), 18 May 2022.
-
1st Workshop on Programming Languages and the Law
(ProLaLa 2022), Philadelphia (USA), 16 January 2022.
-
MIREL workshop on MIning and REasoning with Legal texts.
Luxemburg, 17 September 2018.
- Conference on Recent developments in Artificial Intelligence: Law and Justice.
Montreal (Canada), 27 October 2016.
- ECAI 2016 Workshop on AI for Justice.
The Hague (The Netherlands), 30 August 2016.
- Workshop Responsible Intelligent Systems in Perspective; where Computer Science, Philosophy and Legal Theory meet
Utrecht (The Netherlands), 18-19 April 2016.
- Zif Workshop on Models of Rational Proof in Criminal Law.
Bielefeld (Germany), 28-30 September 2015.
- 2nd International Conference on Quantitative Aspects of Justice and Fairness (QAIJF 2011)
Fiesole, Florence (Italy), 25-26 February 2011.
- IVR 2007 Workshop on Legal Reasoning About Evidence
Krakow (Poland), 4-5 August 2007.
- Conference on Graphic and Visual
Representations of Evidence and Inference in Legal Settings (conference brochure)
New York, USA, 28-29 January 2007.
- Workshop `Dialectical Legal Argument:
Formal and Informal Models'.
Tilburg (The Netherlands), 12 December 1996.
Journals
Research projects
Research Groups, Labs
People
Kevin Ashley
Katie Atkinson
Trevor Bench-Capon
Floris Bex
Karl Branting (obituary)
Tom van Engers
Tom Gordon
Guido Governatori
Matthias Grabmair
John Horty
Daniel Katz
ThorneMcCarty
Dory Reiling
Edwina Rissland
Giovanni Sartor
Marek Sergot
Burkhard Schaefer
Harry Surden
Bart Verheij
Radboud Winkels
Wijnand van Woerkom
Adam Wyner